Towards a concept of Communicative Competence in Health: a qualitative study in medical residents
Despite the wealth of literature surrounding the importance of effective communication in the clinical practice, there is a dearth of consensus in the literature on what communicative competence in health (CCH) is, and the practices of meaningful health communication. Seventeen residents (17) were invited to share their thoughts on the concept of communicative competence in health and on difficulties they encounter during their clinical practice related with communication. The aim of this study was to gain a better understanding of CCH with emphasis on the implications in the medical curriculum, teaching, learning and assessment. Three focus group discussions were conducted with the clinical supervisor. The results were audio-taped, transcribed verbatim and analyzed using principles from grounded theory for qualitative data analysis. The 135 open codes and defined axial codes were discussed and a number of conceptual frameworks were utilized to disentangle the concept of CCH. The focus group themes related to the concept of communication in health, its importance and difficulties, the role of the physician and health personnel. The participants felt their own training did not prepare them to establish effective communication with patients and relatives. Some barriers include lack of time and lack of institutional priority given to communication issues. The techniques originating from grounded theory permitted to define a broader concept of CCH with the following three specific scopes: biological perspective (objective world), social (social world) and subjective world (expressive-aesthetic). This new concept of CCH is central to understanding how the health communication process occurs, where a myriad of individual (physician, patient, staff, relatives), organizational and societal interrelated factors influence health decisions and practice. These components need to be addressed by medicine schools, health institutions and other stakeholders in the planning and designing a new model of curricula.
Published online: 30 June 2015
Anderson, Elizabeth, Jenny Ford, and Thorpe Lucy. “Learning to listen: Improving students’ communication with disabled people.” Medical Teacher 33, nº 1 (2011): 44-52.
Aspegren, Knut. “BEME Guide No. 2: Teaching and learning communication skills in medicine – A review with quality grading of articles.” Medical Teacher 21 (1999): 563-570.
Association of American Medical Colleges. “Report 3. Contemporary issues in medicine: Communication in medicine.” Washington, DC., 1999.
Bascuñan, María. “Cambios en la relación médico-paciente y nivel de satisfacción de los médicos.” Rev Méd Chile 133 (2005): 11-16.
_____. “Desarrollo de habilidades comunicacionales en medicina.” Pediatría al día 21, nº 5 (2005b): 47-50.
Bate, Paul, Peter Mendel and Robert Glenn. Organising for quality: The improvement journey of leading hospitals in Europe and the United States. Oxford: The Nuffield Trust, Radcliffe Publishing. , 2008.
Bombeke, Katrien, Linda Symons, Etienne Vermeire, Luc Debaene, Sandrina Schol, et al. “Patient-centredness from education to practice: The ‘lived’ impact of communication skills training.” Medical Teacher 34 (2012): e338-e348.
Brownell, Judi. “Elwood Murray: Pioneering Methodologist in Communication.” Communication Education 63, nº 4 (2014): 329-343.
Butani, Lavjay, Debora Paterniti, Daniel Tancredi and Su Ting. “Attributes of residents as teachers and role models – A mixed methods study of stakeholders.” Medical Teacher 35 (2013): e1052-e1059.
Cook, David, Georges Bordage and Henk Schmidt. “Description, justification and clarification: a framework for classifying the purposes of research in medical education.” Med Educ 42 (2008): 128-133.
Davidsen, Annette. “Experiences of carrying out talking therapy in general practice: a qualitative interview study.” Patient Educ Couns 72 (2008): 268-275.
De Haes, Hanneke, and Jozien Bensing. “Endpoints in medical communication research, proposing a framework of functions and outcomes.” Patient Educ Couns 74 (2009): 287-94.
Des Jarlais, Don, Cynthia Lyles, and Nicole Crepaz. “Improving the reporting Quality of Nonrandomized Evaluations of Behavioral and Public Health Interventions: The Trend Statement.” American Journal of Public Health 94 (2004): 361-366.
Duffy, Daniel, Geoffrey Gordon, Gerald Whelan, Kathy Cole-Kelly, Richard Frankel, et al. “Assessing Competence in Communication and Interpersonal Skills: The Kalamazoo II Report.” Acad Med 79 (2004): 495–507.
Flaherty, Joseph. “Education and evaluation of interpersonal skills.” In The interpersonal dimension in medical education, edited by Agnes Rezler and Joseph Flaherty, 101-146. New York: Springer Verlag, 1985.
Glaser, Barney. Basics of Grounded Theory Analysis: Emergence Vs. Forcing Sociology Press, USA., 1992.
Hall, Pippa, Erin Keely, Suzan Dojeiji, Anna Byszewski, and Meredith Marks. “Communication skills, cultural challenges and individual support: challenges of international medical graduates in a Canadian healthcare environment.” Medical Teacher 26 (2004): 120-125.
Haskard, Kelly, and Robin DiMatteo. “Physician Communication and Patient Adherence to Treatment. A Meta-Analysis.” Med Care 47 (2009): 826-834.
Hastings, Adrian, Robert McKinley, and Robin Fraser. “Strengths and weaknesses in the consultation skills of senior medical students: Identification, enhancement and curricular change.” Med Educ 40, nº 5 (2006): 437-443.
Haynes, Brian, Elizabeth Ackloo, Navdeep Sahota, Heather McDonald, and Xiaomei Yao. “Interventions for enhancing medication adherence.” Cochrane Database Syst Rev 16, nº 2 (2008).
Herrera, Nelson, María Gutiérrez, Magnolia Ballesteros, Romina Izzedin, and Angela Gómez. “Representaciones sociales de la relación médico paciente en médicos y pacientes en Bogotá, Colombia.” Rev. salud pública 12, nº 3 (2010): 343-355.
Jagosh, Justin, Joseph Boudreau, Yvonne Steinert, Mary MacDonald, and Lois Ingram. “The importance of physician listening from the patients’ perspective: Enhancing diagnosis, healing, and the doctor–patient relationship.” Patient Education and Counseling 85 (2011): 369-374.
Junod, Noelle, Johanna Sommer, Patricia Hudelson, Florence Demaurex, et al. “Clinical supervisors’ perceived needs for teaching communication skills in clinical practice.” Medical Teacher 31 (2009): e316-e322.
Körner, Mirjam, Heike Ehrhardt, and Anne Steger. “Designing an interprofessional training program for shared decision making.” Journal of Interprofessional Care 27 (2013): 146-154.
Kinnersley, Paul, and John. Spencer. “Communication skills teaching comes of age.” Med Educ 42 (2008): 1052-1053.
Kurtz, Suzanne, Jonathan Silverman, John Benson, and Juliet Draper. “Marrying content and process in clinical method teaching: Enhancing the Calgary– Cambridge guides.” Acad Med 78 (2003): 802-809.
Mahmud, Amina, Ewy Olander, Sara Eriksén, and Bo Haglund. “Health communication in primary health care - A case study of ICT development for health promotion.” BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 2013: 13-17.
Markakis, Kathryn, Howard Beckman, Anthony Suchman, and Richard Frankel. “The Path to Professionalism: Cultivating Humanistic Values and Attitudes in Residency Training.” Acad. Med 75 (2000): 141-150.
Mercer, Laura. “Patient perspectives on communication with the medical team: Pilot study using the communication assessment tool-team (CAT-T).” Patient Education and Counseling, 2008: 220-223.
Rees, Charlotte, and Paul Garrud. “Identifying undergraduate medical students’ attitudes towards communication skills learning: a pilot study.” Medical Teacher 23, nº 4 (2001): 400-406.
Rencic, J, A Liles, and Caridad Hernández. “The relationship between patient race and patients’ perceptions of their physicians’ Cultural Competence and Patient- Centered Communication Skills.” Journal of Investigative Medicine 53, nº 1 (2005): S24.
Schaefer, Kristen, and Susan Block. “Physician communication with families in the ICU: evidence-based strategies for improvement .” Current Opinion in Critical Care 15 (2009): 569-577.
Silverman, Jonathan, Suzanne Kurtz, and Juliet Draper. Skills for communicating with patients. First Edition 1998. 2nd ed. New York: Radcliffe Publishing Ltd. , 2013.
Strauss, Anselm, and Juliet Corbin. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. Sage Publications, USA. , 2008.
Szasz, Thomas, and Marc Hollender. A contribution to the philosophy of medicine; the basic models of the doctor-patient relationship. A.M.A. Archives of Internal Medicine, 97(5), 585-592. 1956. http://ezproxy.utp.edu.co/docview/81844107?accountid=45809 (last access: 2 de May de 2012).
Tatossian, Arthur. The Phenomenology of Psychosis. Paris: Masson, 1979.
Universities UK. “Statement of guiding principles relating to the commissioning and provision of communication skills in preregistration and undergraduate education for healthcare professionals Universities UK.” United Kingdom, 2003.
Wanzer, Melissa, Melanie Booth-Butterfield, and Kelly Gruber. “Perceptions of health care providers’ communication: relationships between patient-centered communication and satisfaction.” Health Commun 16 (2004): 363-384.
Watmough, Simon, Anne Garden, and David Taylor. “Does a new integrated PBL curriculum with specific communication skills classes produce Pre Registration House Officers (PRHOs) with improved communication skills?» Medical Teacher, 28, nº 3 (2006): 264-269.
Wittenberg-Lyles, Elayne, Joy Goldsmith, and George Demiris. “The Impact of Family Communication Patterns on Hospice Family Caregivers.” Journal of Hospice and Palliative Nursing 14, nº 1 (2012).
Authors are required to sign and submit a copyright transfer agreement after acceptance but before publication of their manuscript. To that effect, they receive, from the Managing Editor of Tuning Journal for Higher Education, a standard copyright assignment form designed along the following lines:
The author who signs the copyright transfer agreement must be the sole creator of the work or legally acting on behalf of and with the full agreement of all the contributing authors.
2. Copyright and Code of conduct:
a) Authors warrant that their work is original; has not been previously copyrighted or published in any form; is not under consideration for publication elsewhere; its submission and publication do not violate TJHE Ethical Guidelines for Publication and any codes (of conduct), privacy and confidentiality agreements, laws or any rights of any third party; and no publication payment by the Publisher (University of Deusto) is required.
b) Authors are solely liable for the consequences that may arise from third parties’ complaints about the submitted manuscript and its publication in Tuning Journal for Higher Education (TJHE).
c) Authors grant to the Publisher the worldwide, sub-licensable, and royalty-free right to exploit the work in all forms and media of expression, now known or developed in the future, for educational and scholarly purposes.
d) Authors retain the right to archive, present, display, distribute, develop, and republish their work (publisher's version) to progress their scientific career provided the original publication source (Tuning Journal) is acknowledged properly and in a way that does not suggest the Publisher endorses them or their use of the wortk.
e) Authors warrant that no permissions or licences of any kind will be granted that might infringe the rights granted to the Publisher.
Tuning Journal for Higher Education is an Open Access publication. Its content is free for full and immediate access, reading, search, download, distribution and reuse in any medium or format only for non-commercial purposes and in compliance with any applicable copyright legislation, without prior permission from the Publisher or the author(s). In any case, proper acknowledgement of the original publication source must be made and any changes to the original work must be indicated clearly and in a manner that does not suggest the author’s and or Publisher’s endorsement whatsoever. Any other use of its content in any medium or format, now known or developed in the future, requires prior written permission of the copyright holder.